What MMORPG should I get?

I quit WoW due to cataclysm ruining the great world I loved, so now I'm looking for a new MMORPG bandwagon to ride. I've narrowed it down to 2 of em: Rift, Guild Wars. These fit my style of play from what I've seen/heard. I've dabbled a bit in Guild Wars which is why I like, plus that one pay forever ain't too bad either. But my problem with Guild Wars is that I enjoy raiding and being rewarded for it but apparently you don't have to raid to get good gear. But, I heard PvP was kickass, and it looked it from gameplay vids I've seen, which was crazy as hell. From what I hear on Rift, it sounds pretty legit, haven't read up alot on its PvP. BUT I didwatched some gameplay though and seemed like WoW which will make me pretty good at it seeing as how I was sexy at PvP in WoW. Raiding seemed very familiar as well, which also attracts me. So which one? Also if you have any suggestions to other MMORPGs and reasons for it, I would be glad to hear it. Thanks.